You can only gift people items that are on their wishlist - at least through that feature. You can still trade people item to gift them if they're not on a wishlist, but that requires more steps for both people.

If you want to gift someone something, you can go to their user profile and click the "wishlist" button there! (OR go to your own wishlist and swap out the usernames in the URL)

Then you can see what's on their wishlist and gift them things, either anonymously or not.

Hopefully that helps! (Also yes, this is the right place for asking questions like this. :D)

(Also, since I see some custom selection items on your wishlist, I'll let you know a lil tip -- for Custom Items (the ones that are sold by Shady Character in Backstage Broker) the selection items are a bit harder to nab, since you can only get them from Shady. But the individual items are listed in the User Shop of the person who made the item, so if you put a specific colour of the item (like "pink lovesick eyes") on your wishlist, it's easier to buy and easier to gift!)

I have a lot of extra items and shards just from playing the game for a few years, so whenever I gift folks, the best way to repay me is to pay it forward one day when they have a bunch of extra items!! I really love how excited Tattered Weave users are to gift each other things ; u ;

Thank you to both of you for telling me all of that, I really appreciate it!

I've been spending a lot of time on here since I started and love this site already. I hope I'll eventually have a better understanding of how everything works and a large variety of items to gift other users in the future :)

I'm also grateful that you pointed that out Shazzbaa, I didn't realise that, I'll go and check that out now.